The Reporter Life: Writing a Letter to the Editor

“So the writer who breeds more words than he needs, is making a chore for the reader who reads.”
― Dr. Seuss


By Rachel H.T. Mendell

08/01/2017

Letters to the editor may not earn you money, but they are a great way to get your name – and ideas – in print. If you are involved in a local club, group or project, letters to the editor, sent to the newspaper on a regular basis, can bring free attention to what you are doing and can gather readers to your blog or website. Well written letters catch the attention of the public and possible clients.

Before I continue, let’s be clear: A letter to the editor is not a column. It is also not an editorial. If the editor likes your well-crafted letter he may request a longer version to run as a column (happy-dance). The editor may also choose a well-written letter to run as the editorial for the day. As an editor, I have done both, but rarely.

Here are a few steps about composing a letter to the editor: Write out all your thoughts, focus on one idea, rewrite as crisply and concisely as you can, follow the editor’s guidelines, be polite.

Write out all your thoughts

If you’re like me, you feel passionate about a certain thing and want to express that passion to anyone who will listen. We’ll take the subject of chickens as an example. I believe that people living in town should be allowed to keep chickens for the purpose of fresh eggs and meat.

I write down everything I can think of in favor of keeping chickens in town: Independent living, encouraging green space and organic living, self-sufficiency and neighborly help, fresh food production, free fertilizer for home gardens, very little space needed, etc.

Then (and this is important) you must think about how people will argue your points. Chickens are noisy, chickens smell bad, chickens escape, chickens peck people, roosters crow early in the morning and will wake people up that just got off graveyard shift, chickens spread disease, chickens are dirty, etc. Many of these arguments are not true, but because you have heard them, you should consider covering them in your letter to refute the myths.

Once you have all your pros and cons written out, it’s time to check the guidelines for the publication that you hope will take the letter. If you try to cover all the pros and cons I have just mentioned, your letter is too long.

Word Count

Remember the editor doesn’t have a lot of time for editing a letter. It needs to be perfect.

Scenario 1: Editor gets a well-crafted, clearly written letter with no typos, misspellings, or questionable grammar. The word count is within the limit. Editor smiles. Editor places the letter directly under the editorial for the day. Five minutes.

Scenario 2: Editor whispers a nasty cuss word as he reads the first two paragraphs of a jumbled, unclear rant. It goes on and on. Editor considers it because there are valid points.The editor needs letters, but this one will need to be cut and edited. Fifteen minutes at least. Editor isn’t quite sure what Mr. Writer really wants to say. Editor could call Mr. Writer and discuss it, another 20 minutes, but that is on the bottom of his uber-long to-do list. Editor leaves the rant soaking in his inbox.

Scenario 3: Evil Editor announces loudly to staff that Mr. Writer has attempted to get published on the editorial page once again. Editor reads letter out loud to staff. Staff laughs, or applauds, depending how unclear the letter is. Letter is trashed. Officially, Letter is “lost.”

All these events really happened. I am embarrassed to say I have been, on occasion, the Evil Editor.

I think you will agree that we all want Scenario 1, so here’s how you get there.

Stick to One Subject

State your subject, your opinion and perhaps why you disagree with the opinion of someone who wrote a letter a few days before, or a decision made by the school board, or a road closing in your area, or more information about a story that ran previously. Don’t go off on a tangent. Stick to one issue. You can always write another letter.

Make sure to include any facts you have on the subject at hand. Facts add relevance and believability to your stance.

Most people know what they want to write about. They are angry about something that happened: a decision by the government, or a community situation. They are happy about something that happened: a new store opening, the high school got the state championship, a community member achieved something inspirational. They have a question: why isn’t a certain road getting the pot holes filled in, why aren’t the trees trimmed, why is the electricity on Cherry Street going out all the time.

Know the paper you are writing to. As with a letter to a friend, you need to know what your friend is interested in, events in their life, history with you, etc. Choose a paper, study it, request (or go online for) the editor’s guidelines – just like you would a magazine or a blog. Then keep your subject about that community. Editors run letters they know their readers will enjoy, or will produce an emotional response, or get the community united about an issue.

Another safe bet would be to write a response to a newspaper story the paper recently published. Be sincere. Don’t praise a story just because you want to get on the editor’s good side. The newspaper thrives on discussion and argument. If you have additional information on a subject covered in the paper, share it. Remember to mention the story you are responding to with headline, date, and page (“This letter is in response to ‘City going for broke,’ May 15, 2017, Page 1”). This makes is easy for the editor to verify your facts (An editor does not have to verify your opinion). Caution: If you are responding to a newspaper story, your letter may be printed along with a response from the editor.

Some people write a letter and send it to every newspaper they can find thinking they are sending out an alarm to the masses. This may not work because editors can see through that. Editors know editors and will call each other on occasion to chew the fat and joke about that guy that writes letters every week about conspiracies (whether those conspiracy theories are true or not).

Sign Your Name

You can use words like “Thank You,” “Sincerely,” and “All the Best,” before your signature, but it’s not necessary. Steer clear of “Love,” “Hearts and Flowers,” and “From The Front Lines,” unless your letter is attempting to insert a little humor into a depressing subject. I knew a gentleman who wrote about farming and farmer’s concerns and signed it “Out In Left Field.”

Use your real name. Editors know people who know people who know other people. You will be found out.

Include Contact Information

Most newspapers need phone numbers for verification. Check the newspaper’s guidelines.

Aside

There was a gentleman who sent us several emails that contained interesting information, but something didn’t sound kosher. One of my tech ladies did a little investigating and found our gentleman on Facebook. The page had been created suspiciously two weeks before the emails began. I then requested an interview over the phone to ask a few questions. The gentleman never called. We had our suspicions as to who the real person was. Every editor is different, but I had an aversion to calling out elected officials via Letters to the Editor from people with made-up names. However, I did use the information in the emails for pointed questions to aforementioned elected officials.

A Word About Anonymous

As editor of a small paper, I would receive anonymous letters about once a month. The problem with most of them was their libelous nature, insinuations and name calling. I did not print them. I did not want to get caught in a law suit. However, there are instances I think should be anonymous: Ex drug users, victims of abuse, minors, etc.

The Call

You may expect a call from the newspaper, either the editor or one of his staff. They want to verify that you are indeed a real person with a real opinion and not some wingnut  trying to get his jollies by seeing his fake name in print (see “aside” above).

Other General Guidelines and Advice

If you decide to write second letter, make sure you check with how many times you are allowed to be published in any given year. Our newspaper had a guideline of every 30 days. Regular writers carefully dated their letters and stuck to the 30 days. We could count on them to submit like clockwork.

Keep your letter short. Most newspapers don’t accept anything over 300 words.

Good Luck!

P.S. Every editor is different. All the information I just gave you may be completely the opposite of what you need for your local paper. Be prepared for the unexpected.

P.P.S. The New York Times is one of the largest and most influential newspaper in the world. I have learned a lot about journalism and newspaper composition from their example. Here’s what they have to say about sending a letter to them (Good Luck!):

“How to Submit a Letter to the Editor”

“Letters should be exclusive to The New York Times, or The International New York Times. We do not publish open letters or third-party letters.”

“Letters should preferably be 150 to 175 words, should refer to an article that has appeared within the last seven days, and must include the writer’s address and phone numbers. No attachments, please.”

“We regret that because of the volume of submissions, we cannot acknowledge unpublished letters other than by an automated e-mail reply. Writers of letters selected for publication will be notified within a week. Letters may be edited and shortened for space.”

To send a letter to the editor:

For a great article about writing a letter to The New York Times go to:

http://www.nytimes.com/2004/05/23/opinion/23READ.html

Featured photo credit: Inforrm’s Blog


Rachel H.T. Mendell

pib

Bio:

Rachel H.T. Mendell writes freelance from home in her office that she grabbed when her sixth child moved out, which is much nicer than the converted closet she wrote in for almost 20 years. Rachel writes novels, poetry, plays, essays, columns, articles, short stories, long letters, devotionals and experimental allegory. She has been published in various magazines as well as the Galion Inquirer, The Morrow County Sentinel, the Crestline Advocate and online at Richland Source. You can find a few of her articles in Heart of Ohio Magazine and floating around cyberspace. She keeps a blog, Domestic Mobility (http://domesticmobility.blogspot.com), and has recently started a website (http://www.rachelhtmendell.com). Rachel happily answers emails at mendell.rachel7@gmail.com. She is married and has seven children and one grandson. When Rachel is not writing, she’s gardening, caring for chickens, rabbits, and cats. She lives with her family in Morrow County, Ohio.

Published posts on Two Drops of Ink:

1) The Reporter Life

2) The Reporter Life: Writing the Press Release


Two Drops of Ink: The Literary Home for Collaborative Writing

Our published contributors enjoy becoming a part of an established, award-winning blog. They gain exposure from our ever growing audience. In turn, we gain the audience that they bring with their writing. Join the Two Drops of Ink family. Read our submission guidelines and send us your submission.

We have more than 20 wonderful contributing authors who have been published on this site. Check out their bios. Read their work. Visit their sites. Check out our list of ‘Published Contributors.’

Sell your book from our page, ‘The Book Store’

 

Advertisements

S.W. Biddulph

Scott Biddulph is a published writer, author, and poet from North Georgia. He began writing as a youngster and followed his lifelong dream of reaching people through the written word when he returned to The University of North Georgia in 2013 to finish earning his BA/English with a concentration on publication and creative writing. His publications include the following: an eBook, Apples of Gold: A collection of inspirational short stories and poems (Smashwords, 2010) and a paperback, Voices from the Heart, (Createspace, 2012). His poetry is published in Papers and Publications Undergraduate Research Journal. Vol 3 (2014) and the award-winning Chestatee Review (Spring, 2015), among other places (Check his LinkedIn profile for a full list of his publications). He is currently working on publishing poetry, creative non-fiction, academic essays, and his memoir. ******** Scott has also worked as an intern editor for the University of North Georgia Press. As a freelance editor, he has done the layout and design of several books and magazines. He is currently working with several authors on various publication projects in which he is either ghostwriting, editing manuscripts, or doing the layout and design of their books. ******** Finally, and most importantly, he is a father, grandfather, husband, and dedicated Harley Davidson rider. He and his family enjoy the beauty of the North Georgia Mountains where they live—especially their screened in back porch where they love to bird watch. ******** ~ "I love realism. I love writing about the raw, down-to-Earth, heartfelt realities of life. I love to write in a way that reaches into the human soul—to take the greatest pains and struggles in life, and make them a blessing to others. Fantasy is a wonderful, interesting thing—but real-life situations, feelings, fears, and dreams are an unexplored ocean of stories that need to be told." ~ ~Scott Biddulph~

15 comments

  1. Thank you for this very informative and inside look at writing letters to the editor, Rachael. I loved reading about the different types of people who submitted. I bet you have a lot more stories you could write from your time as newspaper editor. I hope you’ll share some more here!
    Oh and my neighbor had a rooster who crowed at 5AM every morning including weekends 😦 lol!

    Liked by 1 person

    • I DO have a lot more stories … I decided to hide them in a book (if you know what I mean) … maybe that will be my NaNoWriMo project for this November! … oh, when we first moved here the neighbor raise roosters – they crowed All Day Long – and at night too. Our rooster is sort of a watch dog … he crows whenever someone is walking or driving up our 660 ft driveway. We have a tiff now and again … but you know how roosters are … :o)

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Hi, Rachel. A very informative post presenting details I wasn’t aware of. Possibilities for advancement from writing letters is most enlightening. Certainly, numerous writers will gain important insight with this intriguing information. Thanks for posting this very interesting piece!

    Liked by 2 people

  3. Wow Rachel! Many times I have wanted to write to my local news editor about issues I felt strongly about. I appreciate this lesson on how to address a news editor properly. I found your post informative and will be referring to it when I need it. Thank you, your contribution to this site has been helpful in many ways. John.

    Liked by 2 people

  4. Hi, Rachel. With so many people “sounding off” via Facebook and other social media, I think this post is helpful if you actually want something aired in your hometown, about your elected officials, why something is or isn’t being done by the city counsel, or just to thank those who still labor at the paper.

    My Dad wrote letters to the editor, mostly published, and you’re right, it helped solidify his reputation for integrity in the poultry industry – GA being what it is, that certainly helped our family.

    As always, you’ve given us a lot to digest, much appreciated.

    Liked by 3 people

    • Thanks, Marilyn! We had several responsible citizens that spoke up from time to time and I loved getting letters from them – they were balanced, fair, fact-based and asked the hard questions. Sometimes those letters would be referred to or quoted at the next city council meeting. Sometimes those letters changed the minds of the council members. That is when I did the happy dance (inside my head) because that’s what the paper is all about. Connecting people to people to people … and watching the government. Blessings!

      Liked by 2 people

    • Hey! Take the plunge! I can tell you from speaking with other editors … letters are few and far between … especially the thoughtful ones. Blessings!

      Liked by 2 people

  5. From the late 1990s to the middle 2000s I wrote about 100 Letters to the Editor. About 75 were published in my hometown paper, The Morning Call of Allentown Pa. One was published in the Philadelphia Inquirer and one was read on air on the Fox News channel.
    Eventually, people asked me to run for City Council in Allentown. I ran twice and narrowly lost both times but, met many interesting people including the current Mayor of Allentown who is facing 54 counts of fraud resulting from an FBI investigation into Pay to Play schemes.
    Writing Letters to the Editor can be a very rewarding experience even if there is no financial reward. Everyone wants to “put their two cents in”.

    Liked by 4 people

    • Excellent! wow … how exciting! Those stories are what reporters live for … I covered a murder, several drug busts, court proceedings of a city that sued a hospital for pulling out and a finance officer that lost tons of money and trusted the wrong people (and that was small-town America) … so, um … did he do it? Did the paper do an investigation? Who blew the whistle? … the heart of a reporter never dies … LOL Blessings!

      Liked by 2 people

Join the conversation. We welcome your thoughts and ideas!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s